One of the representatives of the Almighty on Earth, Franciscan friar Paolo Benanti, has raised concerns about the behavior of billionaire tech entrepreneurs, referring to their “tendency to play God.”
Benanti, a prominent figure in the Vatican advising the Pope on technology matters such as artificial intelligence (AI) and deepfakes, has been actively involved in assessing AI’s societal impact for the Italian government. His recent appointment to investigate AI’s effects on the media led him to engage in discussions in Rome with notable figures like Bill Gates and Italy’s prime minister, Giorgia Meloni.
In a recent interview, Benanti criticized the paternalistic approach prevalent in Silicon Valley, where tech magnates exhibit a desire to impose their idea of “doing good” on society, often without regard for individual preferences. He particularly called out the concept of “effective altruism,” which advocates for maximizing charitable efforts, suggesting that tech billionaires feel entitled to determine how their wealth should be allocated, surpassing governmental roles.
Drawing attention to ethical dilemmas, Benanti posed thought-provoking questions like whether one should save a drowning man if he is related to historical figures like Hitler. He cautioned against the notion of individuals assuming the role of saviors and highlighted the dangers of prioritizing profit-driven AI applications over ethical considerations.
Expressing skepticism about the intentions of tech elites, Benanti emphasized the need for a philosophical underpinning in their pursuits, pointing out a quest for spirituality that sometimes manifests in unconventional practices like engaging with shamans and psychedelic substances. He hinted at a deeper yearning for a sense of purpose and connection beyond material gains, suggesting that the search for meaning transcends mere technological advancements.
Ultimately, Benanti’s reflections shed light on the complex interplay between technology, ethics, and human values, urging a more profound contemplation of the implications of wielding power in the realm of AI.
