Tech industry groups are pushing back against President Joe Biden’s executive order on artificial intelligence (AI), expressing concerns that it could hinder innovation. While the order has been positively received by AI experts and government officials, organizations like NetChoice, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA) have raised objections, citing ambiguities and the potential to stifle creativity.
NetChoice, representing major AI firms such as Amazon, Google, and Meta, cautioned that the broad regulatory scope outlined in Biden’s order could deter new businesses from entering the market and grant excessive authority to the government over technological advancements. Carl Szabo, NetChoice’s vice president and general counsel, emphasized that stringent regulations could impede investment in AI and undermine the U.S.’s reputation as an innovation hub.
The Chamber of Commerce acknowledged the order’s positive aspects but highlighted areas that necessitate further refinement. Tom Quaadman, the executive vice president of the Chamber’s Technology Engagement Center, pointed out concerns regarding tight timelines for agency actions, which could lead to hasty decision-making and hinder inter-agency collaboration.
The comprehensive order addresses various AI-related challenges, including privacy risks and procurement policies, while also promoting the involvement of different organizations in advancing AI technologies within the government sector. Despite some technical executives welcoming the order as a step in the right direction, there are calls for broader industry representation beyond the major tech players to ensure a more inclusive approach.
SIIA expressed support for the order but raised reservations about its potential impact on innovation and American technological leadership. Paul Lekas, SIIA’s senior vice president for global public policy, cautioned against overly prescriptive measures that could impede technological progress and hinder the U.S.’s competitive edge in AI development.
While the Biden administration has not yet responded to these concerns, it is evident that the debate surrounding AI regulation will continue, with a focus on balancing innovation with regulatory oversight. Despite differing opinions within the tech industry, there is a recognition of the need for effective and balanced AI governance to drive technological advancements while safeguarding against potential risks.
